There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from fighting something for a long time only to learn later that you had the wrong opponent. Not the wrong problem. The problem was real. The door really was stuck, the answer really was withheld, the thing you wanted really did not come. But the hand on the other side of the resistance was not the hand you thought it was, and that changes everything about how hard you should have been pushing, and in which direction, and for how long.
Hannah knew exactly what she wanted. A child, a name to give, a way to stop being measured by what her body had not produced. She wanted it badly enough to refuse her portion at the table, badly enough to pray with her mouth moving and no sound coming out, badly enough that a watching priest mistook her grief for drunkenness. Nobody would call that resistance mild. She brought the full weight of her want into the temple and set it down in front of God.
What she never seems to do, in the account we have of her, is treat that want as something to war against on her own behalf. She does not bind anything. She does not declare the enemy defeated over her body. She names her condition an affliction and asks God to remember her, and the word remember there does not mean God forgot. It means something closer to now, Lord. Now would be the time. She is not fighting a spiritual battle against a hostile force keeping her from what is hers. She is asking the one holding the door shut to open it.
The text says plainly that it was God who had closed her womb. Not a rival power. Not bad luck. The obstacle at the center of her prayer came from the same source she was praying to. She was asking God to remove something God himself had placed there.
If she had spent those years treating the closed door as something to break down by force, she would have spent her strength opposing the very one she needed to open it for her. That’s the part that doesn’t resolve neatly. Her longing wasn’t wrong. Her grief wasn’t a lack of faith. The resistance she felt was completely legitimate. And it still turned out to be the wrong thing to fight.
Most of us have learned one way to hold a closed door: press against it, declare it opposition, wait for the breakthrough. It’s not a bad instinct. Some doors are exactly that. But Hannah’s story suggests there’s another kind of door, one that looks identical from the inside, where the resistance is real and the timing is not yet and the one who could move it is the one you’re already talking to. You don’t find out which kind you’re facing by how hard it resists. You find out, if you find out at all, only afterward, and sometimes not even then.
So what do you do with a door that will not open when you cannot tell from where you are standing whether it is shut against you or being held for a time? Whether the years of asking are warfare or waiting? Whether you should keep pushing or place the full weight of what you want before God and leave it there again?
Hannah does not give us a formula for knowing. She gives us a picture of someone who kept bringing her real grief to God without first deciding what the resistance meant. The door eventually opened. The resistance had been real all along. It had simply had the wrong name.
Leave a comment